top of page
Is History Being Replicated?
A perspective on the Black Stance In America through Black Voting and Black Homeownership

Historical Replication: Welcome

Intro
Historical Replication: Text
One can look at pictures of society from the early 1900s compared side to side and see clear, concise changes throughout history. However, according to experts and scholars, a look at the current standing of America’s Black Community is anything but clear. In fact, C. Bradley Hunt II head of the Greensboro, North Carolina chapter of the NAACP in a recent interview stated “I see striking resemblances between 1909 and 2021! I do believe history is being replicated.”. This article purpose is to provide info as to whether or not history is being replicated by viewing the stance of the Black Community in America through Systematic interactions: Voting Rights and Housing Disparity.
Historical Replication: Text
History Replication? Yes or No?
Historical Replication: Video

Black Voting
Historical Replication: Text
According to Free at Last, A History of the Civil Rights Movement and Those Who Died In The Struggle(Bullard,1989) Blacks newly freed from slavery and brought under the wing of the United States via the 13th and 14th Amendments, as well as the Civil Rights Act of 1866, now found themselves labeled as citizens but unable to move in the complete capacity of citizens. The Fifteenth Amendment passed in 1869, giving Black Men the right to vote. According to sources and Aclu.org, the next year Louisiana passes the Grandfather Clause to keep former slaves and their descendants from voting. This act was followed by four other southern states, plummeting the amount of Black votes.The NAACP was and The Civil Rights Movement was formed in 1953 in order for Blacks to combat all forms of mistreatment and inequality. One of the movements main focal points was the voting. Black voters had met with blockade after blockade when it came to too voting, particularly in the south where the high umbers of African Americans threatened to upset the supposed status quo. According to the History Channel these barriers ran from anything from poll taxes to literacy test, and even physical battery.
One famous event in this timeline was the Selma to Montgomery March were a peaceful group marching to vote was met by troops and were beaten with batons, tear gas and whips in order to deter them from voting. President Lyndon B Johnson then signed into ratification The Voting Rights Act of 1965 and slowly things began to change. Fast forward to today and how are Blacks doing with voting? There are far more Black registered voters with records now mentioning Black “turn out” ads in meaning how many decided to participate in voting which signifies that it has become common place. And common place often means things are not as difficult and more readily accepted. But does readily accepted mean truly accepted? The U.S Justice Department recently sued Georgia over the bill SB 202. The Department of justice is suing says it is aimed at restricting the Black Vote. Activists claim these type of restrictions have not been seen since Jim Crow. Myrna Perez the director at the Brennan Center, also states that an analysis done by the center shows the bill is aimed to “disproportionately hurt voters of color”. Other predominately Republican states such as Arizona, Wisconsin, Michigan, and Pennsylvania amongst have also enacted new voter restrictions in a similar manner and a considered a part of the movement the U.S Justice department says it is combating. What does this say for the stance of Black America that fifty six years later not one, not ,two but fourteen states according to CNN have enacted laws making it harder for African Americans to vote?
Historical Replication: Text
Historical Replication: Pro Gallery

Black Housing
Historical Replication: Text
Housing disparity came from segregation. Segregation was were societal restrictions were put in place limiting the interactions of the Black Community with White American Society. This segregation extended to many areas such as the housing which lead to noticeable differences in how both races are Blacks and whites are housed overall. According to experts in 1933 America faced what it called a housing shortage which means that it did not have the means to provide living quarters for its citizens at the rate at which they were growing. The Federal Government then came up with a plan to increase the available housing while segregating it at the same time. They used a process called “Redlining” in which they outlined districts on loacal maps according to who stated where, outlining Black or mixed areas in red and in some cases refusing to lend loans or aid these areas in any way. While in other cases the gave these areas aggressive loans rates, penalties for early pay offs, and flat out deception at times. To help increase home ownership even more Federal Based programs such as the Home Owner’s Loan Corporation and the Federal Housing Administration were made to encourage home ownership and development of the suburbs by offering Whites loans with cheaper rates and affordable mortgages. This aside with zoning laws according to experts, tended to enforce residential segregation as Whites tended to only sell to other Whites and their neighborhood tended to work in clauses stating no Blacks were allowed in the neighborhood. Meanwhile the Black Area with worse or no loans tended to fall behind quick on payments. This was housing discrimination. A lot of this land would end up seized by the Government or banks. And then under the term Urban Renewal also known as “Slum Clearance” which started in 1950, the Government would then proceed to tear down these once predominately Black areas displacing thousands of Black families to make way for White Communities while shoving the poor disenfranchised Blacks into “affordable housing” or ghettos. This lasted in its entirety from 1933 to 1965 with both the Federal Housing Authority and the Veterans Administration issuing out 120 Billion worth of new housing with a quote of 98% of the money going to Whites. The Fair Housing Act was passed to 1968 as a remedy to this.
Fast forward to 57 years and how is housing in America for Blacks? The numbers of suburban Blacks has increased above since the early 1960s, this is true. However, according to statistics from the U.S Censusand Urban.org Blacks are currently so close to the same level and percentage that it is hard to tell there was even any gains. Discriminatory practices allowed banks and lenders to deal unfairly with Black charging more and sometimes deceiving them out right. Today outright deception is not allowed, but Blacks still are buying homes at higher rates than both Whites and Asians. On average Blacks are offered sub-prime or lower loans with higher interest rates despite often qualifying for the same Prime loans given to the White or Asian communities according to Bloomberg.com. The same banks that once took the stance of ignoring the African American Community that sought to now shows an interest in them by way of targeting through commercial practices. And Black renters were also fairing worse than other races according to Black Renters Could afford 16 percent of Rentals in 2017, an excerpt that states that Black could only afford less than 30 percent of rentals on Zillow that Whites and Asians could afford. Matthew Desmond, an assistant professor of Sociology and social studies at University, said” Between 1991 and 2013, the percentage of renter households in America dedicating under 30 percent of their income to housing costs fell from 54 percent to 43 percent. During that same time, the percentage of renter households paying at least half of their income to housing costs rose from 21 percent to 30 percent. African American and Hispanic American families, the majority of whom rent their housing, were disproportionately affected by these trends. In 2013, 23 percent of black renting families and 25 percent of Hispanic renting families spent at least half of their income on housing”. According Metropolitan Decentralization, Transit Dependence, and the Employment Isolation of Central City Black Workers the great majority of metropolitan Blacks remain concentrated in the central cities of the largest statistical areas, despite having the option to move to the suburbs.
Historical Replication: Text

Conclusion
Historical Replication: Text
How far has America advanced since the thirties, sixties and Civil Rights movement for Black America? Is History being replicated? Some may look at the past presidency of Barack Obama and feel like the majority of the fight is in the past and that African American Community has come far. Others might look at voting, lending, and housing discrimination and feel that the fight is a long way from over and that Blacks have not seen any real advancement according to the American doctrine of Equality. According to both theories, most would be hard pressed to say the other doesn’t mean anything or is not true. Recent events however, the passing of an Anti-Discrimination Bill for Asians while ignoring 400 years of harsh treatment towards Blacks seems to be calling the question of Black advancement to the forefront. All have heard the anecdote “Actions speak louder than words!” and in this setting of America where both beauty and ugliness have reared their heads on multiple occasions, it seems the most fitting answer to this question of "is history being replicated?". Take a long hard look at the actions of America, what do they say to you?
Historical Replication: Text
(Extra)The Black Mindset as a By Product
Historical Replication: Video
bottom of page